3Commas vs Coinrule: which trading bot wins in 2026?
Head-to-head on the facts that decide your money: custody model, pricing, features and scores - every number sourced in the linked reviews.
Short answer: Coinrule wins overall (7.5/10 vs 7.1/10 in our weighted scores). 3Commas is still the better pick if you care most about features. Facts verified 2026-09-03.
 3Commas |  Coinrule | |
|---|---|---|
| Overall score (0-10) | 7.1 | 7.5 |
| Safety score | 6 | 6.5 |
| Custody model | Exchange API keys | Exchange API keys |
| IP whitelisting | yes | no / unclear |
| Pricing model | Monthly subscription | Free tier + paid plans |
| Entry price | $15-140/mo | 0.02% of volume |
| Free tier / trial | 3-day trial | free tier |
| Exchanges | 10 | 20 |
| Grid bots | yes | no / unclear |
| DCA bots | yes | yes |
| TradingView signals | yes | yes |
| Futures | yes | no / unclear |
| Backtesting | yes | no / unclear |
| Paper trading | yes | no / unclear |
| Open source | no / unclear | no / unclear |
| US available | yes | yes |
| Company | 3C Trade Tech Ltd. | Coinrule Ltd |
// 3Commas at a glance
The most established cloud bot platform - deep features, real API-key incident history, now OAuth-hardened.
++ What works
- Broadest bot portfolio: DCA, grid, signal, options bots
- OAuth Fast Connect with IP whitelisting
- Pine Script strategy execution
- Works with US-accessible exchanges
- Crypto payments accepted
-- What to watch
- 2022 API-key leak with two-month denial phase
- BVI-registered vendor, offshore legal seat
- Bot limits scale with expensive plans
- Recurring-subscription cost regardless of performance
// Coinrule at a glance
The easiest no-code entry into bot trading - if-this-then-that rules across crypto, on-chain and even stocks, with a real free tier.
++ What works
- Genuinely beginner-friendly visual rule builder
- Free tier plus $29.99 Investor plan
- Trades on-chain (Base, Arbitrum, Ethereum) and stock brokers too
- MCP integration for AI agents
- YC-backed with named founders
-- What to watch
- Volume-capped plans ($3k free / $500k Investor) throttle active traders
- Pro tier at $749/mo is aimed at businesses
- No grid/futures bot templates in the classic sense - rules-based only
// FAQ
Which is safer, 3Commas or Coinrule?
Custody models first: 3Commas: exchange api keys with IP whitelisting, Coinrule: exchange api keys. If a platform needs your API keys, use IP-whitelisted trade-only keys and keep only working capital on the exchange - the 2022 key-leak lesson. Security incident history per platform is documented in each review.
Which is cheaper, 3Commas or Coinrule?
3Commas costs $15-140/mo (monthly subscription); Coinrule costs 0.02% of volume (free tier + paid plans). Compare against your volume: subscriptions are flat cost while per-trade fees scale with activity - the bot cost calculator shows your break-even.
Which has more features, 3Commas or Coinrule?
3Commas: grid DCA signals futures arb copy AI backtest paper code . Coinrule: DCA signals AI MCP . Feature parity matters less than the two or three you actually use - check the grid/DCA/TradingView flags in the table above.
Scores and facts: meta-reviews with dated sources - 3Commas · Coinrule. Method: how we verify. More: all trading bots compared.